The interdental papilla (IDP) represents the pyramidal shaped tissue formed by connective tissue covered by oral epithelium and has a complex morphological, anatomical, and vascular structure. The combination of pristine gingiva and natural dentition is the best way to sustain oral health. Any deficiency of the papilla beneath the contact point of the teeth creates a black triangle that may lead to an increase in food and plaque accumulation and an inefficiency of self-cleansing action that may eventually progress to periodontal disease1,2. The systemic interlink between general and oral health has already been proven; thus, the loss of IDP may negatively impact the overall health of an individual3. During the last decade, maintaining good oral health has become a major concern as well as a challenge in patients who require periodontal regenerative therapy. The regeneration of IDP especially in esthetic regions is among the most difficult treatment due to its anatomorphological situation and peculiarity of blood supply.
The existing literature reveals that several authors have tried different techniques to regenerate the IDP with discrete outcomes. Beagle4 reported on a surgical pedicle roll technique that was used to regenerate the lost IDP. Azzi et al.5 achieved surgical thickening of the gingiva and reconstruction of the IDP around an implant using a connective tissue graft (CTG). Kaushik et al.6 created an advanced papillary flap with interposed CTG that can be used to reconstruct the IDP if papillary loss occurs solely due to soft-tissue damage. Azzi’s study7 reported gingival and papillary reconstruction using autogenous osseous and CTGs. In their case report, Carranza and Zogbi8 showed reconstruction of the IDP with an underlying CTG.
In the present scenario, regeneration is the key to the success of many treatments. Periodontal regeneration is now possible to a great extent with the use of advanced biomaterials like the amnion or chorion membrane9. Clinicians have used diverse periodontal biomaterials to reconstruct the IDP. Geurs et al.10 used a micronized acellular dermal graft in interproximal papillae regeneration. Gupta et al.11 suggested that both the amnion and chorion membranes are biocompatible and safe to use and do not cause any inadvertent tissue response or antigenic reactions. With the advancement of minimally invasive periodontal therapy, the novel human amnion-chorion membrane (ACM) tissue collected during Caesarean sections from the placenta has been widely utilized in the field of dentistry. ACM has showed successful gingival recession coverage, but its efficacy for papillary recession coverage is yet to be proven due to a lack of scientific research12.
Therefore, the aim of our present study was to regenerate Nordland and Tarnow’s Class I and II papillary recession defects with the use of ACM allografts and also to evaluate the clinical outcomes up to six months postoperatively.
In this present multi-center, prospective
After the initial selection process, a comprehensive plaque control program was initiated three weeks before the procedure that included oral hygiene instruction, patient education, and motivation. All patients were in good health; they had a pocket depth ≤4 mm, good plaque control, and tooth mobility scores of 0. All patients with blood disorders, pregnant or lactating mothers, and tobacco users were excluded from the study population.
Informed written consent was obtained from the participants who fulfilled the inclusion criteria and voluntarily agreed to participate. A thorough explanation was given regarding the possible nature, risk, and benefit of the clinical investigations and the associated procedure3. The study was strictly performed according to the Declaration of Helsinki. Special care was taken to protect the confidentiality of the participants. A photographic image analysis was carried out preoperatively at baseline and then again at three and six months postoperatively and considered for statistical analysis. The ACM was purchased from the tissue bank of Tata Memorial Hospital in Mumbai. A tissue lab authority confirmed that the international protocol and standards were maintained from the time of tissue procurement until packaging. The safety of using the allograft was also ensured.
On the day of the surgery, local anesthesia was achieved by infiltrating the area with 2% lignocaine (Loxicard, lignocaine hydrochloride injection, 50 mL; NEON, Chennai, India). The papillary recession height and width were measured with a periodontal probe on the buccal surface. The ACM allograft was cut to double the size of the papillary recession height and width. First, a semilunar incision approximately 6-10 mm apical from the gingival margin was placed on the labial aspect between the distolabial line angles of the involved teeth14. Next, an intrasulcular incision was made around the mesial half of both the adjacent teeth to free the gingival attachment from the roots. An Orban interdental knife was then used to detach the gingivo-papillary unit from the underlying connective tissue to create a pouch-like space. The entire gingivo-papillary unit was also pushed coronally.(Fig. 1. A) The semilunar incision allows for coronal displacement without creating tension and prevents rebounding of the coronally advanced gingival position14. To maintain this new papillary position, the previously measured ACM allograft was then stuffed into the pouch space.(Fig. 1. B) Once the dry ACM came in contact with the blood present in the surgical field, it was quickly hydrated and became supple. Then, the semilunar incision was sutured with interrupted 4-0 non-resorbable black silk sutures (Ethicon NW 3319 non-absorbable surgical suture; Johnson & Johnson, Mumbai, India). Primary hemostasis was confirmed, and a periodontal dressing was placed. Fifteen days after surgery, suture removal was performed.
The patients were instructed to follow a soft, cold diet for three days postoperatively. They were prescribed analgesic antiinflammatory medication (Diclofenac sodium 50 mg, four times a day; Troikaa Pharmaceuticals, Ahmedabad, India) for three days. For persuasive plaque control, 10 mL of a 0.2% chlorhexidine mouth rinse (Chlohex ADS; Dr. Reddy’s Laboratories, Hyderabad, India) was prescribed twice daily. A supportive periodontal therapy was performed weekly for the first four weeks and then monthly until the termination of the study period.
Photographs were taken (Nikon D5300 DSLR Camera; Nikon India, Gurgaon, India) at baseline (Fig. 1. C), three months postoperatively (Fig. 1. D), and six months postoperatively for evaluation.(Fig. 1. E) Paramount care was taken to maintain a similar photographic angulation and distance at the different follow-ups to allow a proper image analysis process (at a distance of 2 ft from the patient, on macro mode, with the flash off, in natural sunlight, in autofocus mode). Once all the photographs were gathered, an image analysis was carried out using GNU Image Manipulation Program (GIMP) image analysis software, a free bitmap graphics editor. This software program calculates the number of tiny rectangular black pixels arranged in a grid formation, and the pixels are then transfigured into a physical length in millimeters. The entire process was done in GIMP by measuring the size of pixels of the reference object/line in the image. The difference between the maximum and minimum height was represented with “y” coordinates within a designated area, while the width was shown using “x” coordinates that were prearranged by the computer program. The mesial to distal width of a central incisor was used as the reference distance. The wedge of the black triangle was judiciously measured and demarcated on the image. Then, the black triangle height (BTH) and the black triangle width (BTW) were automatically translated into a physical length (mm). To attain the outcome, the contrast was enhanced in such a way that the dark portion on the photograph representing the deficient papillae showed up as completely black, while the remainder of the image was converted to white15.
The acquired data were processed through Microsoft Excel 2000 (Microsoft, Redmond, WA, USA), and the statistical analysis was carried out using the IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows (ver. 20.0; IBM, Armonk, NY, USA). The mean and standard deviation values for all the parameters were calculated at the baseline and then again at three and six months postoperatively. A
The results of this study included a clinical as well as a photographic analysis-based augmentation of recession defects at three and six months postoperatively.(Fig. 2) A statistically highly significant difference was observed for both the BTH and the BTW at the three- and six-month follow-up assessments (
From the available literature, it is clear that the shape and health of the IDP are important for maintaining IDP hygiene via a self-cleansing mechanism; its absence may create problems in both esthetics and phonetics16,17. Together, these conditions can lead to a dearth of self-esteem; for individuals with a high lip line, it may become highly troublesome to the extent that the patient may avoid smiling due to a lack of self-confidence18. Thus, regeneration of lost IDP should be attempted in these individuals. Regeneration defines the re-growth of the lost tissues from the remaining portion. Although conventional autogenous tissue-based regenerative procedures may provide a good result, they also create a secondary donor site, which increases the morbidity associated with the procedure and also reduces patient acceptance. Regenerative medicine is a more modern approach that attempts to change the course of chronic diseases and tries to regenerate tissue in many ways.
Our present study attempted to regenerate missing tissue in Nordland and Tarnow’s Class I or II papillary recession defects by combining an ACM allograft with a semilunar coronally advanced flap (CAF). The results of this study showed a statistically significant improvement in papillary augmentation from the baseline until three months and six months after the procedure was performed (
Previous studies that have created a CAF in conjunction with autogenous CTG or bone grafts have reported a stable and predictable outcome5-7. Nevertheless, the need to harvest an autograft unavoidably creates a secondary surgical site, which also increases the morbidity, surgical time, and risk of postoperative hemorrhaging or complications and therefore reduces a patient’s willingness to undergo this procedure.
In contrast, evidence from increasing clinical use has proven the excellent efficiency of human placental allografts19. ACMs acquire antimicrobial and immune privilege properties that are conferred as a scaffold protein and thereby encourage cell migration to the area of interest. Current research has suggested that placental tissues are a good source of mesenchymal stromal cells20.
Novel ACM and placental allograft membranes are primarily a cryo-preserved and dehydrated laminate of amnion-chorion (dHACM). The unique distinctive properties of ACMs incorporate the presence of laminin-5 and growth factors like platelet-derived growth factor, fibroblast growth factor, and transforming growth factor beta21. It has been speculated that these proteins aid in rapid granulation over the allograft. dHACM demonstrates an enhanced growth factor expression profile and stromal derived factor 1 expression, which triggers inhabitant cells. ACM is therefore an appealing therapeutic modality because its structural component provides a scaffold for regeneration. The recruited cells show self-renewal and differentiation properties and are localized near the sites of neovascularization, which is condemnatory for regeneration22.
ACM allografts have been extensively used to heal ophthalmic surfaces, burn sites, and diabetic foot ulcers. The amniotic extracellular substance is beneficial in regenerating peripheral nerves. De-cellularized amnion-chorion can be used as a nourishing layer for stem cells obligatory for neuronal differentiation23. ACM has been successfully used to treat chronic cutaneous wounds and exhibits a low immunogenicity and a reduction in inflammation and pain24. The exact mechanism of action of fetal membranes’ clinical benefits has yet to be fully determined22.
In recent years, ACM has also been studied for periodontal regeneration and has shown promising results. Studies have been conducted using either amnion or chorion or as the ACM membrane to treat gingival recession, periodontal intrabony defects, and furcation areas with or without bone grafts. To the best of our knowledge, no clinical study has investigated using ACM as a gingival papillary regenerative material, although researchers have achieved successful soft tissue gains in various clinical situations12. Brain observed an increase in new gingival tissue that represented 97%±0.5% root coverage when ACM was used in a moderate recession defect25. Chakraborthy et al.12 found a mean decrease in the length of recession with a chorion membrane of 2.00±1.54 mm and an amnion membrane of 1.58±1.14 mm. Suresh and Gupta26 reported a statistically significant gain of relative clinical attachment (
The aforementioned clinical studies clearly illustrate the tremendous potential of ACM in the field of soft tissue regenerative therapy. It was a wise option to combine ACM with a CAF to treat mild to moderate papillary recession. One possible explanation for the successful papillary fill with ACM when placed beneath a CAF could be explained by the fact that it acts as a potential source of stem cells and growth factors and enhances neo-angiogenesis. The potential of ACM to self-adhere eliminates the need for suturing28. An
The widespread use of ACM has been restricted by concerns with its source along with difficulties in preparation and storage and also the potential for infectious disease transmission. Current developments in tissue processing and establishing an international protocol have addressed these ethical issues. Fetal membranes obtained during Caesarean section deliveries are thoroughly washed in a sodium chloride isotonic medical solution. The amniotic-chorion is then gently separated and slit into sections. It is thoroughly washed sequentially in 0.5 M, 1.0 M, and 1.5 M solutions of dimethyl sulfoxide and is finally stored at –80°C. Since the 1980s, a series of research on ACM has failed to detect human leukocyte antigen or β2-microglobulin in cultured amniotic epithelium, which led to its reported safety30.
Thus, within the limitations of our study, we conclude that ACM can be used in combination with a semilunar CAF technique as an alternative novel papillary regenerative therapy.
The minimally invasive reconstruction of the IDP with an allograft offers new hope for eliminating the black triangle. The successful use of this procedure may benefit both patients and clinicians in terms of causing minimal trauma and offering an easier or comparatively simpler procedure than an autogenous soft tissue graft. In the future, papillary regeneration around dental implants may significantly benefit from this concept of alternative material-based reconstruction.
The growing cosmetic demand from patients has solidified the importance of gingival esthetics. An intact IDP plays a prime role in maintaining a holistic esthetic appearance. Our current study showed that the ACM along with coronal advancement of the interdental unit had an enhanced beneficial effect on the regeneration of lost interdental papillary tissue. In addition, proper patient selection, surgical skills, and an adequate maintenance protocol are also crucial for successful outcomes.
We would like to thank the department head of the Tissue Lab at Tata Memorial Hospital in Mumbai for providing us with ACM for this research. We would also like to thank the department head of the Oral Radiology, Modern Dental College and Research Center in Indore for guiding us with our image analysis.
All authors contributed equally to this work. U.P., P.C.P., R.B., and M.V. participated in the study design, clinical procedure, data collection, data analysis and primary preparation of manuscript. A.B. and S.K. performed the image analysis, statistical analysis, wrote the manuscript and helped to draft the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
This study was approved by the Institutional Ethical Review Board of the Modern Dental College and Research Center in Indore, India (IRB No. MDCRC-2018-01-02A), and written informed consent was approved by the IRB.
Written informed consent was obtained from the patients for publication of this article and accompanying images.
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
The values of all the parameters measured at the baseline and then again at three-month and six-month intervals
|Parameter||Time interval||Mean±SD or mean difference (mm)||F-value|
|BTH||Baseline to 3 mo||1.04120||0.01
|Baseline to 6 mo||0.97600||0.01
|3 mo to 6 mo||–0.06520||0.955|
|BTW||Baseline to 3 mo||0.78650||0.01
|Baseline to 6 mo||0.75650||0.01
|3 mo to 6 mo||–0.03000||0.983|
(SD: standard deviation, BTH: black triangle height, BTW: black triangle width)