Journal of the Korean Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons : eISSN 2234-5930 / pISSN 2234-7550

Table. 4.

Table. 4.

Overview of included case reports and case series

Study Possible cause Age of onset (yr) Age at diagnosis (yr) Sex Diagnostic imaging Mouth opening diagnosis (mm) Coronoid hyperplasia Surgical intervention Surgical approach Intraoperative mouth opening (mm) Supportive postoperative intervention Postoperative mouth opening (mm) Follop-up (mo)
Acharya et al.7 (2017) NA 13 16 M OPG, MRI, CT 15 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Therabite 27 3
Akan and Mehreliyeva32 (2006) NA 20 24 M MRI, CT 15 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 30 NA
Baraldi et al.33 (2010) Fetal trauma (twin) Since adolescence 21 F MRI, CT 12 Right Coronoidectomy Intraoral 30 Physiotherapy 35 7
Bayar et al.9 (2012) Trauma 19 yr 19 21 M OPG, CT 23 Right Coronoidectomy Extraoral (preaurcular)+ intraoral NA Physiotherapy 38 NA
Bronstein and Osborne34 (1984) Trauma 2 yr NA 20 M OPG, tomo, fluoro 20 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA 30 Physiotherapy, ultrasound, pulsed galvanis stimulation 39 3
Capote et al.35 (2005) Trauma 2 yr 17 23 F OPG, CT 30 Unilateral Coronoidectomy+ arthroscopy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy NA 12
Choi et al.36 (2013) No history 12 13 M CT, MRI 15 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 45 NA 40 4
Choi et al.36 (2013) NA 13 13 M OPG, MRI, CT 20 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 50 NA 45 6
Choi et al.36 (2013) NA 16 16 OPG 15 Bilateral Redo coronoidectomy Intraoral 45 NA 42 12
Colquhoun et al.37 (2002) Trauma 29 yr 29 32 M OPG, CT 21 Bilateral Right coronoidectomy Intraoral NA NA NA 18
Colquhoun et al.37 (2002) NA 23 26 M OPG, CT 22 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 35 NA 22 30
Costa et al.16 (2012) No history NA 18 M OPG, CBCT, MRI 20 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 50 5
de la Torre et al.38 (2001) NA 17 19 M Tomo, RX 7 Left Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy NA NA
de la Torre et al.38 (2001) NA 14 16 NA OPG, CT 14 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 55 NA 22 4
de la Torre et al.38 (2001) NA 16 NA Unknown 25 Bilateral Coronoidectomy+ debridement and stretching Intraoral 52 Physiotherapy 49 12
Duffy39 (1980) NA NA 15 M Unknown 8 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 30 Physiotherapy NA 30
Fernández Ferro et al.30 (2008) NA NA 28 M OPG, CT 13 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Therabite 40 12
Fitzpatrick40 (1970) NA 18 27 M Tomo 5 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 22 Physiotherapy 40 24
Galiè et al.41 (2010) NA A few months old 3 F CT 5 Unilateral left Coronoidectomy+ fasciotomy and myotomy Extraoral (coronal) NA Physiotherapy 30 18
Gerbino et al.42 (1997) NA 14 15 M OPG, Water's view, CT 15 Unilateral right Right coronoidotomy Intraoral 46 Physiotherapy 41 12
Gerbino et al.42 (1997) NA 15 32 M OPG, Water's view, CT 20 Bilateral Coronoidotomy Intraoral 42 Physiotherapy 38 60
Gerbino et al.42 (1997) NA 12 14 M OPG, Water's view, CT 12 Unilateral right Right coronoidotomy Intraoral 46 Physiotherapy 48 60
Gerbino et al.42 (1997) NA 10 13 M OPG, Water's view, CT 18 Bilateral Coronoidotomy Intraoral 40 Physiotherapy 38 15
Gerbino et al.42 (1997) NA 14 16 M OPG, Water's view, CT 20 Bilateral Coronoidotomy Intraoral 38 Physiotherapy 45 60
Ghazizadeh et al.6 (2017) NA Childhood 30 M OPG, CT 21 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy NA 3
Giacomuzzi43 (1986) No history 11 19 M OPG, tomo 11 Bilateral No surgery (refused by patient) No surgery No surgery NA No surgery No surgery
Gibbons et al.66 (2001) NA 16 28 M OPG, CT 15 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Right extraoral, left intraoral 30 Interdental screw appliance 40 NA
Gibbons and Abulhoul31 (2007) NA 16 36 M OPG, CT 20 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 30 Therabite 38 12
Hayter and Robertson44 (1989) No history 15 16 M RX 22 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Bicoronal NA Physiotherapy NA 1
Huang et al.45 (2020) NA When she was young 59 F OPG, CT, MRI 25 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA 41 NA 30 15
Inoue et al.46 (2020) NA Junior high school In his 50s M OPG, CT 18 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 30 6
Khadembaschi et al.25 (2020) Mucopolysaccharidosis 12 14 M CT 8 Bilateral Coronoidectomy, removal of zygomatic arch exostoses Intraoral+ bicoronal 40 Therabite 45 18
Kim et al.15 (2014) NA 13 43 M OPG, MRI, CT 25 Bilateral No surgery (refused by patient) No surgery No surgery NA No surgery No surgery
Kim et al.15 (2014) NA NA 21 M MRI, CT 28 Right Coronoidectomy NA 43 Physiotherapy 63 15
Kim et al.15 (2014) NA 15 19 M MRI, CT 32 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA 35 Physiotherapy 65 18
Kim et al.15 (2014) NA 18 18 M CT 12 Right Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy 54 15
Kraut47 (1985) NA NA 38 F OPG 14 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 43 Physiotherapy 27 11
Kraut47 (1985) NA 17 17 M OPG, CT 19 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 40 Physiotherapy 40 2
Kreutz and Sanders48 (1985) NA 44 54 F OPG, Water's view 16 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Submandibular 50 Physiotherapy 45 24
Lee and Chung14 (2012) Somatropin 12 17 M OPG, CBCT 10 Bilateral Coronoidectomy left submandibular, right intraoral 53 NA 40 1
Leovic et al.49 (2006) NA 17 35 M CT 15 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy 35 NA
Loh et al.50 (1997) NA 12 14 M RX 13 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 22 Physiotherapy 37 3
Loh et al.50 (1997) NA NA 41 M NA 15 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 25 Physiotherapy 25 NA
Loh et al.50 (1997) NA 18 22 M NA 5 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Extraoral NA Physiotherapy 20 NA
Loh et al.50 (1997) NA NA 25 F NA 16 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 30 NA
Lucaya et al.51 (1982) NA 9 9 F RX 22 Right Coronoidectomy NA NA NA Normal NA
Mano et al.52 (2005) No history 5 6 M OPG, tomo, CT 17 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 40 72
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 1 7 M NA 12 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 17 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 7 8 F NA 15 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 39 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 12 13 M NA 22 Bilateral No surgery No surgery NA Physiotherapy NA NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 8 13 M NA NA Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy NA NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 11 13 M NA 14 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 29 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 17 17 M NA 13 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 38 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA NA 18 M NA NA Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy NA NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 13 18 M NA 19 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 35 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 13 18 M NA 21 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 33 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 14 19 M NA NA Bilateral No surgery No surgery NA Physiotherapy NA NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 1 21 M NA 10 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 21 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 21 25 M NA NA Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy NA NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 31 31 M NA 29 Bilateral No surgery No surgery NA Physiotherapy NA NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 24 34 M NA 22 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 29 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 22 33 F NA 4 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 35 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA NA 33 M NA 17 Bilateral No surgery No surgery NA Physiotherapy NA NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 34 34 M NA 22 Bilateral No surgery No surgery NA Physiotherapy 40 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 26 36 M NA 13 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 28 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 16 36 M NA 48 Bilateral No surgery No surgery NA Physiotherapy NA NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 23 43 M NA 18 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy NA NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 36 44 M NA NA Bilateral NA NA NA Physiotherapy NA NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA NA 47 F NA 21 Bilateral No surgery No surgery NA Physiotherapy NA NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 58 78 M NA 13 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 29 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 2 3 M NA 13 Unilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 14 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 13 15 M NA 22 Unilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 40 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 14 18 M NA 20 Unilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 25 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 7 19 M NA 19 Unilateral Coronoidectomy Extraoral NA Physiotherapy 24 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA NA 29 M NA NA Unilateral NA NA NA Physiotherapy NA NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 16 31 M NA 25 Unilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 38 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 20 32 M NA 17 Unilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 25 NA
McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) NA 40 42 F NA 18 Unilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy NA NA
Monevska et al.53 (2016) NA NA 3 F OPG, CT 2 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 30 Therabite 25 NA
Monks54 (1978) Difficult extraction 11 50 M RX 8 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral right, extraoral left 20 Physiotherapy 20 24
Puche et al.24 (2012) Kabuki syndrome (hypotonia) Congenital 0.67 M CT 9 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 22 Physiotherapy 24 27
Puche et al.24 (2012) Pena-Shokeir syndrome (hypotonia) Congenital 0.83 M CT 11 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 24 Physiotherapy 24 25
Ramalho-Ferreira et al.55 (2011) No history 23 26 M OPG, CT 19 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 29 Physiotherapy 31 30
Romano et al.56 (2017) NA NA 37 M OPG, MRI, CT 16 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 39 Physiotherapy+ Therabite 39 12
Romano et al.56 (2017) NA NA 25 M OPG, MRI, CT 20 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 38 Physiotherapy+ Therabite 40 12
Romano et al.56 (2017) NA NA 43 M OPG, MRI, CT 13 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 41 Physiotherapy+ Therabite 39 12
Romano et al.56 (2017) NA NA 27 M OPG, MRI, CT 19 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Extraoral (preaurcular) 47 Physiotherapy+ Therabite 45 12
Romano et al.56 (2017) NA NA 29 M OPG, MRI, CT 13 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Extraoral (preaurcular) 38 Physiotherapy+ Therabite 43 12
Romano et al.56 (2017) NA NA 23 M OPG, MRI, CT 17 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Extraoral (preaurcular) 39 Physiotherapy+ Therabite 40 12
Rowe et al.57 (1963) No history 12 15 M RX 15 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Mechanical exerciser 35 14
Rowe et al.57 (1963) No history 13 15 M RX 10 Bilateral No surgery (refused by patient) No surgery No surgery NA No surgery 36
Satoh et al.58 (2006) No history 12 13 M OPG, CBCT 27 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 40 Physiotherapy 45 8
Schneble et al.59 (2019) No history 0 4 M CT 15 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA 25 None 15 60
Shurman67 (1975) Facial injury 2 yr prior 42 44 M RX 22 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA 22 Physiotherapy 40-50 Next few weeks
Smyth and Wake10 (1994) Adenoidectomy 8 15 M RX, CT 4 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral+ bicoronal 50 Physiotherapy 23 12
Smyth and Wake10 (1994) Adenoidectomy 8 23 M OPG, CT 11 Bilateral Redo coronoidectomy Intraoral+ bicoronal 40 Physiotherapy 50 12
Starch-Jensen and Kjellerup3 (2017) No history NA 18 M OPG, CBCT 22 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 42 Physiotherapy+ Therabite (not motivated) 32 3
Tavassol et al.60 (2012) NA 11 13 M CT, MRI 10 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 48 NA Still normal NA
Tieghi et al.70 (2005) Trauma, age 4 yr 13 15 M CT 25 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 40 Bite block, physiotherapy (butterfly jaw exerciser) 46 6
Tieghi et al.70 (2005) No history NA 17 F OPG, CT 25 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 40 Bite block, physiotherapy (butterfly jaw exerciser) 40 20
Totsuka and Fukuda68 (1991) No history 14 17 M RX,OPG, CT 17 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 45 Physiotherapy+ mechanical extenser 52 10
Totsuka and Fukuda68 (1991) No history 10 13 M RX, CT 29 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 48 Physiotherapy 45 3
Tucker et al.61 (1984) No history 14 16 M OPG, tomo, CT 22 Unilateral right Coronoidectomy Intraoral 40 Physiotherapy 44 3
Turk et al.23 (1999) Moebius syndrome At birth 1.5 M CT 8 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA NA 25 4
Turk et al.23 (1999) Moebius syndrome At birth NA NA CT 10 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 30 NA 40 NA
Utsman et al.69 (2013) NA 9 12 M CBCT 15 Bilateral (right>left) NA NA NA Daily exercises NA 2
Wallender et al.22 (2015) Prematurity, duplication of chromosome 7P21.1 0 0.16 M CT 4 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 25 Jaw physiotherapy 25 1 wk
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) NA NA 2 F NA 10 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite 25 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) AS NA 45 M NA 10 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite 31 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) NA NA 16 M NA 14 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite 40 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) NA NA 18 M NA 16 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite >30 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) NA NA 24 M NA 18 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite 40 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) NA NA 5 F NA 4 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite 32 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) CNS disorder, hypertonic muscles NA 35 M NA 5 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite 31 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) NA NA 23 M NA 10 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite 23 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) AS NA 38 M NA 7 Right Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite 35 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) NA NA 53 F NA NA Left Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite >30 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) NA NA 4 M NA NA Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite >30 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) NA NA 14 M NA 15 Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite 33 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) CNS disorder, hypertonic muscles NA 28 M NA NA Bilateral Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite >30 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) NA NA 18 F NA NA Left Coronoidectomy NA NA Physiotherapy+ Therabite >30 NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) AS NA 52 M NA 22 Left NA NA NA NA NA NA
Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) AS NA 56 M NA 25 Bilateral NA NA NA NA NA NA
Yamaguchi et al.63 (1998) NA 17 25 M CT 24 Left Coronoidectomy Intraoral NA Physiotherapy 43 8
Yoshida et al.64 (2008) Bilateral hypertrophy of masseter muscles 28 34 F RX, CT, MRI 18 Bilateral Redo coronoidectomy Intraoral 44 NA 38 6
Yura et al.65 (2009) No history 15 28 M OPG, CT 30 Left Coronoidectomy Intraoral 50 Physiotherapy+ mouth opening exerciser 43 15
Zhong et al.17 (2009) No history 26 39 F OPG, CT 8 Bilateral Coronoidectomy Intraoral 40 Physiotherapy 31 9

(NA: not available or not correctly reported, M: male, F: female, OPG: orthopantomography, MRI: magnetic resonance imaging, CT: computed tomography, tomo: tomography, fluoro: fluoroscopy, CBCT: cone-beam computed tomography, RX: X-ray, AS: ankylosing spondylitis, CNS: central nerve system)

J Korean Assoc Oral Maxillofac Surg 2022;48:133~148
https://doi.org/10.5125/jkaoms.2022.48.3.133
© JKAOMS