Journal of the Korean Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons : eISSN 2234-5930 / pISSN 2234-7550

Table. 3.

Table. 3.

Quality assessment for every included case report or case series

No. Study 1 2 3 4 5 6
1 Acharya et al.7 (2017) + ? + + + +
2 Akan and Mehreliyeva32 (2006) + ? + ? ? +
3 Baraldi et al.33 (2010) + + + + + +
4 Bayar et al.9 (2012) + + + ? ?
5 Bronstein and Osborne34 (1984) + + + ? +
6 Capote et al.35 (2005) + + + +
7 Choi et al.36 (2013) + + ? + ? +
8 Colquhoun et al.37 (2002) + ? ? - -
9 Costa et al.16 (2012) + + + + + +
10 de la Torre et al.38 (2001) + ? + ? ?
11 Duffy39 (1980) + ? + +
12 Fernández Ferro et al.30 (2008) + ? + + + +
13 Fitzpatrick40 (1970) + ? + + + +
14 Galiè et al.41 (2010) + ? + + + +
15 Gerbino et al.42 (1997) + ? + + + +
16 Ghazizadeh et al.6 (2017) + ? + +
17 Giacomuzzi et al.43 (1986) + + + + + +
18 Gibbons et al.66 (2001) + ? + ? ? ?
19 Gibbons and Abulhoul31 (2007) + ? + + + ?
20 Hayter and Robertson44 (1989) + + + + +
21 Huang et al.45 (2020) + ? + +
22 Inoue et al.46 (2020) + ? + + ? +
23 Khadembaschi et al.25 (2020) ? + + + + +
24 Kim et al.15 (2014) ? + + v +
25 Kraut47 (1985) + + + + + +
26 Kreutz and Sanders48 (1985) + ? + + + +
27 Lee and Chung14 (2012) + + + +
28 Leovic et al.49 (2006) + + ? ? ? ?
29 Loh et al.50 (1997) + ? + ? ? +
30 Lucaya et al.51 (1982) + ? ? ? ?
31 Mano et al.52 (2005) + + + + + +
32 McLoughlin et al.8 (1995) + ? + ? ?
33 Monevska et al.53 (2016) + + + ? ? +
34 Monks54 (1978) + + + + + +
35 Puche et al.24 (2012) + + + + ? +
36 Ramalho-Ferreira et al.55 (2011) + + + + + +
37 Romano et al.56 (2017) ? + +
38 Rowe57 (1963) ? + + +
39 Satoh et al.58 (2006) ? + + + + +
40 Schneble et al.59 (2019) + + + ? +
41 Shurman67 (1975) + + ? ?
42 Smyth and Wake10 (1994) ? + + + + +
43 Starch-Jensen and Kjellerup3 (2017) + + + + + +
44 Tavassol et al.60 (2012) + + ? ?
45 Tieghi et al.70 (2005) + + + + + +
46 Totsuka and Fukuda68 (1991) + + + + + +
47 Tucker et al.61 (1984) ? + + + + +
48 Turk et al.23 (1999) + ? +
49 Utsman et al.69 (2013) + + ? ? ?
50 Wallender et al.22 (2015) + + + + +
51 Wenghoefer et al.62 (2008) + + + ?
52 Yamaguchi et al.63 (1998) + + + + + +
53 Yoshida et al.64 (2008) ? + + + ? +
54 Yura et al.65 (2009) + + + + + +
55 Zhong et al.17 (2009) ? + + + + +

Refer to Table 2 for the content of questions 1 to 6.

J Korean Assoc Oral Maxillofac Surg 2022;48:133~148
https://doi.org/10.5125/jkaoms.2022.48.3.133
© JKAOMS