Journal of the Korean Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons : eISSN 2234-5930 / pISSN 2234-7550

Table. 5.

Table. 5.

Comparison of the reviewed studies regarding the implant height and bone height/bone gain and bone loss after the healing period and during the follow-up period

Study Implant height
(mm)
Mean bone height/bone gain after the healing period (mm) Bone height/bone gain during the follow-up period after prosthesis delivery (mm) Bone loss after the healing period (mm) Bone loss during the follow-up period after prosthesis delivery (mm)
Artzi et al.33 (2003) 10 or 13 4.3 (2.5-6) NM NM NM
Barone et al.25 (2008) 10, 11.5, 13 NM 4.2±1.4 No significant bone loss NM
Kolhatkar et al.12 (2011) 12, 13 1-4 NM No crestal bone loss around implant neck NM
Bruschi et al.24 (2013) 13, 15 Mean height of 7.99±1.16 Mean height at 1 yr: 8.05±1.58
Mean height at 2 yr: 8.03±1.49
In long-term: 8.01±1.46
NM NM
Taschieri and Del Fabbro31 (2011) NM NM NM NM At 12 mo: 0.36±0.19
McCrea26 (2012) NM No change was noted in sinus floor bone NM NM
Mandelli et al.29 (2013) NM NM NM NM NM
Crespi et al.27 (2013) 10, 13 At 70 days: 2.63±1.01
At 1 yr: 4.03±1.18
At 2 yr: 4.08±1.25
NM NM
Ebenezer et al.28 (2015) NM NM NM NM NM
Falcón30 (2015) 13 Gain: 4.5 NM NM NM
Chen et al.32 (2017) NM NM NM Mean marginal bone height: 0.63 and 0.73
Liu et al.15 (2019) NM NM NM Test group:
0.65±0.12 (alveolar bone shrinkage on buccal side)
0.3±0.10 (alveolar bone shrinkage on palatal side)
0.60±0.18 (bone loss in vertical direction on buccal side)
0.24±0.12 (bone loss in vertical direction on palatal side)
Test group:
0.21±0.12 (alveolar bone shrinkage on buccal side)
0.12±0.09 (alveolar bone shrinkage on palatal side)
0.21±0.11 (bone loss in vertical direction on buccal side)
0.15±0.08 (bone loss in vertical direction on palatal side)
Sun et al.21 (2019) 10 NM NM NM

(NM: not mentioned)

Values are presented as mean (range) or mean±standard deviation.

J Korean Assoc Oral Maxillofac Surg 2021;47:411~426
https://doi.org/10.5125/jkaoms.2021.47.6.411
© JKAOMS